Sedation
Esmeralda R. Banda, DDS
Compromised Care and Hospital Dentistry Fellow
Texas A & M University -—Baylor College of Dentistry, Dallas, TX
Texas A&M College of Dentistry
Dallas, Texas, United States
Dan Burch, DDS, MA
Texas A&M College of dentistry
Nina Ray, DDS
Texas A&M College of dentistry
Marvellous Akinlotan, DDS
Texas A&M College of Dentistry
Eliska Gautheir, DDS
Texas A&M College of dentistry
Nina S. Ray, DDS
Texas A & M College of Dentistry
Dallas, Texas, United States
Dan Burch, DDS
Texas A&M/Baylor
Dallas, Texas, United States
Aim: Emergence delirium is a postoperative complication that may occur in patients who undergo sedation/general anesthesia. A literature review was conducted to demonstrate the difference, if any, of precedex and propofol on emergence delirium.
Methods: This paper reviews propofol and precedex on emergence delirium literature from 2019-2023. Literature search was conducted electronically using MEDLINE/PubMed database. MeSH terms included the following: “Propofol”, “precedex”,” emergence delirium” and “anesthesia”. Inclusion criteria: Clinical trials, human subjects, case report, articles written in English, randomized controlled trials, retrospective reviews and electronic chart reviews. Exclusion criteria: Non-human subjects, retrospective reviews not involving sedation or anesthesia, and research that primary focused on propofol and precedex.
Results: This literature review identified 9 papers that met inclusion criteria; 748 patients were in a double-blinded, randomized controlled study, aged 65 and older, with 732 patients in the final sample. One clinical study involving 150 children identified regimen with propofol bolus and precedex infusion had better findings on reducing post operative delirium as compared to the use of either agent alone. One meta analysis literature demonstrated that the time in applying agent does make a difference in reducing the incidence of emergence delirium. Another study involving children undergoing cleft palate surgery suggests that precedex is superior to propofol in lowering ED.
Conclusion: This literature suggests that the use of precedex was found to be more effective in reducing emergence delirium compared to propofol. Despite its superiority, clinical practitioners must still consider the pros and cons prior to choosing a sedative agent.